Apéro débat — Résultats

En accès libre

Résultats du débat - Les femmes broyées

Tuesday, 31 January 2023

Résultats des apéros débats autour de l'oeuvre « Les femmes broyées » qui ont eu lieu pendant les expos et partout dans le monde.

font size decrease font size increase font size
Print
Email

Temps de lecture : 1 min

RESULTS

Below are the responses from all participants who have answered the questions since the questionnaire was created. These results combine responses from all countries, all men and women, and all age groups.

To view detailed statistics by country, gender or age group, click the "Results" button (symbol ) below each question.

Pour lancer le débat « Les femmes broyées » et répondre aux questions, cliquez sur le bouton ci-dessous.

Le débat

Les femmes broyées

PDF

Total Responses: 2

1. Me, I believe you?

The feminist slogan "Me, I believe you" assumes a presumption of guilt for men. Should women who file rape complaints be automatically believed?

A. Yes, men are bad. All guilty by default. (0% / 0 votes)

B. No, this is no longer justice, it's revenge. It's a slogan of feminists at war against men. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

C. Yes, believing women does not prevent believing men. We can believe both, with the same principles of caution and circumspection. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

D. No, neither should be believed. One should believe evidence, facts, and actions, not people. (0% / 0 votes)

Total Responses: 2

2. #MeToo, the Solution?

The hashtag '#MeToo' denounces sexual assaults on social media. Should sexual assault perpetrators be denounced on social media?

A. No, this is denunciation, public lynching, which leads to automatic sanctions with no possibility of defence. (0% / 0 votes)

B. Yes, this liberation of women's voices leads to collective awareness, the opening of investigations, and judicial convictions. (0% / 0 votes)

C. No, we must not confuse justice with vengeance. Liberating women's voices yes, lynching men no. (0% / 0 votes)

D. Yes, because the justice system turns a blind eye. A measured and proportionate collective sanction is a good solution. Of course, we must not go to extremes either. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

E. No, the risk of error is too great. If we make a mistake, we lynch an innocent man. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

F. Yes, even though we sometimes make mistakes, the risk of error is acceptable. There are always collateral casualties. (0% / 0 votes)

Total Responses: 2

3. An overly guilt-inducing interrogation?

Women complain of undergoing a veritable police interrogation that makes them feel guilty when they report a rape. Should police subject complainants to an interrogation?

A. No, it's not necessary, they are all telling the truth. (0% / 0 votes)

B. Yes, it's the least one can do. Many women exaggerate, amplify, distort, alter facts or lie. (0% / 0 votes)

C. No, the role of police officers is to record complaints in their register, not to judge them. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

D. Yes, the role of police officers is to conduct an investigation, not to provide therapy. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

Total Responses: 2

4. Too long prescription periods?

With prescription periods getting longer, complaints are being filed later and later, making it almost impossible to gather evidence or testimonies. Should we encourage women to file complaints earlier by reducing the prescription period?

A. No, on the contrary! The statute of limitations must be extended, to give women time to find the courage to file a complaint. Shortening the deadlines amounts to suppressing cases. (0% / 0 votes)

B. Yes, they should be reduced. Filing a complaint after 20 years serves no purpose. To be effective, action must be taken within days of the assault. (0% / 0 votes)

C. No, we can encourage them through means other than reducing prescription periods. This is a work of listening and dialogue that the whole society must undertake. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

D. Yes, reducing these timeframes avoids deploying police officers on crimes that cannot be solved and allows for increasing manpower on other crimes. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

Total Responses: 2

5. Is It All About Education?

Feminists often link the upbringing of boys to sexist and sexual assaults. Are parents responsible for their children's sexist and sexual assaults?

A. No, not at all. Parents are not responsible for their children's mistakes, only for their successes. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

B. Yes, parents who poorly educate their children are irresponsible. They should be sanctioned. (0% / 0 votes)

C. No, one shouldn't exaggerate, parents do what they can. You don't choose your children. (0% / 0 votes)

D. Yes, teaching boys to put their feet on the table while girls take care of the house later generates sexist men. It's all a matter of education. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

E. No, there are other factors that come into play in a child's education: school, media, video games... Everything is everyone else's fault. (0% / 0 votes)

Total Responses: 2

6. The Family Environment, a Special Setting?

When aggression occurs within the family setting, women often remain silent to avoid depriving their children of a father, or their mother of a husband. Should there be lesser sanctions for aggression within the family?

A. No, on the contrary! We must be even stricter. We must also condemn mothers who, for example, allow violent stepfathers or rapists into their children's lives. (0% / 0 votes)

B. Yes, lower sanctions encourage victims to file complaints. Without a complaint, the aggressor is never sanctioned and can repeat their actions indefinitely. (0% / 0 votes)

C. No, having a bad father condemned to 5 years in prison is JUST as traumatic for a child as having him imprisoned for 15 years. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

D. Yes, having a bad father condemned to 5 years in prison is FAR LESS traumatic for a child than having him imprisoned for 15 years. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

Total Responses: 1

7. All Liars?

Out of modesty, shame, or discretion, women lie to those around them about the circumstances of their assaults. These lies end up turning against them during police investigations, as they provide their attackers with proof that they are liars. Should we believe women who have lied to their loved ones about the circumstances of their assault?

A. Yes, lying to one's loved ones is not the same as lying to the justice system. Only the version given to the judicial authorities matters. (0% / 0 votes)

B. No, one cannot ignore the testimonies of close ones, as they can also exonerate innocent people. (0% / 0 votes)

C. Yes, the justice system can understand that a woman might lie out of modesty, shame, or concerns for discretion, but this must be clearly stated when filing the complaint. (100% / 1 vote)

100%

D. No, if she has given multiple versions how can one know? Credit must be given to all testimonies. Both to the testimonies of those who heard the first version, and to those who heard the last version. (0% / 0 votes)

Total Responses: 2

8. Rape or sexual assault?

Due to insufficient evidence, many rape cases are reclassified as sexual assault. With significantly lower penalties, victims suffer from a sense of injustice and even impunity. Should penalties for sexual assault be increased?

A. Yes, much harsher sanctions are needed. Too often, perpetrators walk free from court, even when they have been found guilty. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

B. No, there must be a gradation in sanctions. Sexual assault is less serious than rape. (0% / 0 votes)

C. Yes, and we must even broaden the legal definition of rape, so that sexual assaults are reclassified as rape. (0% / 0 votes)

D. No, it's better to focus on prevention, to encourage victims to report rape more effectively, to act more quickly, and to be more meticulous when collecting evidence. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

Total Responses: 2

9. Supporting complainants?

When the justice system turns its back on them, victims suffer a second violence – that of denial. Often, complainants sink into despair, self-destruct, and give up the fight. Should psychological and social support for complainants be established?

A. Yes, absolutely and it is urgent to act. The justice system kills through its denial and indifference towards women. (0% / 0 votes)

B. No, this is not the role of the justice system. There are already sufficient provisions to address the social or psychological needs of French citizens. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

C. Yes, it is necessary to at least monitor the impact of judicial decisions on the mental health of plaintiffs, to prevent suicide attempts. (50% / 1 vote)

50%

D. No, there are too many complainants, it's practically impossible. It's up to the family or those close to them to take over. (0% / 0 votes)

Total Responses: 1

10. Toxic Masculinity?

Toxic masculinity, rape culture, femicide, violence against women, men rape, kill and assault women. Is there a problem with men?

A. Yes, men are bad. They must change and deconstruct themselves. (100% / 1 vote)

100%

B. No, hatred is not gendered. We ignore women's violence and place a magnifying glass over that of men. (0% / 0 votes)

C. Yes, men are becoming increasingly violent, in a society that is increasingly liberating women's voices. (0% / 0 votes)

D. No, there is a problem with everyone. Men's physical violence simply causes more visible damage. Violence can also be verbal, moral or psychological but it is not visible. (0% / 0 votes)

Written by Christian Drouet

Published in Résultats des débats

Tagged under

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

Posting comment as a guest. Sign up or login to your account.

Name (Required)

Attachments (0 / 3)

Share Your Location

Résultats du débat - Les femmes broyées

RESULTS

Les femmes broyées

1. Me, I believe you?

2. #MeToo, the Solution?

3. An overly guilt-inducing interrogation?

4. Too long prescription periods?

5. Is It All About Education?

6. The Family Environment, a Special Setting?

7. All Liars?

8. Rape or sexual assault?

9. Supporting complainants?

10. Toxic Masculinity?

Comments (0)

Leave your comments

LES PLUS LUS DE CETTE CATEGORIE

1Résultats du débat - Les inégalités salariales

2Résultats du débat - La paternité imposée

3Résultats du débat - Pouvoir sexe et subventions

4Résultats du vrai ou faux - Paris golden ticket

5Résultats du débat - Le biberon woke

Catégories

Résultats du débat - Les femmes broyées

RESULTS

Les femmes broyées

1. Me, I believe you?

2. #MeToo, the Solution?

3. An overly guilt-inducing interrogation?

4. Too long prescription periods?

5. Is It All About Education?

6. The Family Environment, a Special Setting?

7. All Liars?

8. Rape or sexual assault?

9. Supporting complainants?

10. Toxic Masculinity?

Text Answers

Comments (0)

Leave your comments

LES PLUS LUS DE CETTE CATEGORIE

1Résultats du débat - Les inégalités salariales

2Résultats du débat - La paternité imposée

3Résultats du débat - Pouvoir sexe et subventions

4Résultats du vrai ou faux - Paris golden ticket

5Résultats du débat - Le biberon woke

Catégories